Indie book reviews

IndieReader’s reviewers are tough, but fair

Our Reviewers won’t judge your book as compared to other self-published titles, but against other books, period. Our ratings are based on the following criteria, although reviewers are able to award partial stars (i.e. a 1.3 or a 4.7), rather than rounding up or down to a whole or half number.

1/5

Really bad 
Work on it.

2/5

Mediocre
1-2 bright spots.

3/5

Good
Worth reading.

4/5

Very Good
1-2 spots that need work

5/5

Excellent!
Must-read.

* IndieReader receives compensation for most of the books it reviews, along with copies of those books.

IR Approved
May 2, 2025

THEA

By Genevieve Morrissey
Rating:
4.8 / 5.0

Genevieve Morrissey's THEA is a heartwarming historical novel with believable characters who are easy to root for in spite of—or perhaps because of—their stubbornness and...

May 2, 2025

FRAIL BLOOD

By Edward Stanton
Rating:
3.9 / 5.0

A lush romance in the classic style of 20th-century Latin America, Edward Stanton’s FRAIL BLOOD evokes writers like Isabel Allende while failing to avoid some...

IR Approved
May 2, 2025

SHAKE THE JAR

By Kevin Barry O'Connor
Rating:
4.6 / 5.0

Kevin Barry O'Connor's SHAKE THE JAR blends action-thriller, a little science fiction, and history into a compelling story.

IR Approved
April 30, 2025

ROBOT: A Deadly Love Story

By Cathy Parker
Rating:
4.4 / 5.0

ROBOT: A Deadly Love Story is an entertaining and well-constructed near-future fable. Under the guise of a sci-fi romance, Cathy Parker examines what it means...

IR Approved
April 30, 2025

DOWNRIVER: Memoir of a Warrior Poet

By Ryan McDermott
Rating:
4.0 / 5.0

A deeply personal memoir of struggle, Ryan McDermott’s DOWNRIVER: Memoir of a Warrior Poet is a valuable addition to the corpus of veterans’ voices in...

Rating:
3.8 / 5.0

Intellectually ambitious and stylistically dense, Mark Seinfelt's A MEAL FOR A MINOTAUR AND FIVE COMPANION ESSAYS is a demanding read best suited for those prepared...

IR Approved
April 28, 2025

FLEET LANDING

By Wendy Gee
Rating:
4.0 / 5.0

Wendy Gee’s FLEET LANDING is a gripping, percussive procedural framed by the structural violence of capitalism and racism in modern America.

IR Approved
April 28, 2025

OF THE SUN AND SEA

By Melissa K. Magner
Rating:
5.0 / 5.0

Dense and dramatic yet heartfelt and relatable, Melissa K. Magner's OF THE SUN AND SEA is both a beautiful fantasy adventure and a poignant metaphor...

Rating:
3.8 / 5.0

I.S. Noah's PEANUT BUTTER AND JELLY SANDWICHES FROM OUTER SPACE! (A TWENTY-FIRST-CENTURY FAIRY TALE) contains many lively passages, but it could benefit from more judicious...

April 25, 2025

THE LOST JOURNAL

By James D Marshon
Rating:
3.0 / 5.0

Although the target audience for James Marshon’s THE LOST JOURNAL is somewhat unclear, it still boasts a stock of amusing anecdotes and a loquacious, energetic...

IR Approved
April 25, 2025

THE TANGLED MANE

By Charlie Tyler
Rating:
4.5 / 5.0

Set among the quaint charm of the Welland Valley, Charlie Tyler's THE TANGLED MANE is an engrossing, fast-paced mystery with a cast of colorful characters...

April 23, 2025

A POSITIVE LOSS EMERGENCE

By Lutz Barz
Rating:
1.5 / 5.0

Lutz Barz's A POSITIVE LOSS EMERGENCE contains some interesting ideas, but it struggles to get its point across due to issues of structure and style.

Get A PROFESSIONAL REVIEW FOR YOUR BOOK!